19 Bridesmaid Proposal Ideas They'll Never Forget - It May Make Them Cry

Looking for bridesmaid proposal ideas that are not only bang for buck but also will make your bridesmaids ecstatic with you?

I have been a bridesmaid more than once and have received my fair share of downright simple proposal ideas to more extravagant ones.

Let’s face it – it’s one of the sweetest memories you will have with your girlfriends.

However, there are also many ways to propose to them, and it has to fit their personality as well as your overall wedding theme.

Ah…that seems a lot to think about, but don’t worry, I have over 19 unique bridesmaid proposal ideas that may touch them so much, it might result in an emotional YES, I will be your bridesmaid!

So, let’s get started!

Disclaimer:

Some of the links on here are affiliate links and I may earn if you click on them, AT NO EXTRA cost to you. Hope you find the information here useful! Thanks.

Table Of Contents

Why Should You Even Do A Bridesmaid Proposal?

Sure, it looks trendy on all the social media, but after being both a bride and a bridesmaid (twice!), I can tell you that it is a heartfelt way to honor your friendship.

This group of people are your ride or dies, or even the ones you hugged as you went through your breakups. Some of them may even serve as your emergency contacts!

A meaningful proposal sets the tone for the entire wedding experience and lets your true friends know what being in the inner circle truly means.

What to Include in a Bridesmaid Proposal

Let’s look into what a “typical” bridesmaid proposal includes:

– A handwritten note
– A memorable keepsake
– Wedding details (date, location, theme, and overall style)

So now that you know what to expect, let’s get into the fun parts of the proposal ideas!

19 Unique Bridesmaid Proposal Ideas

1. Customized Bridesmaid Proposal Boxes

You can easily get something customised with their initials and your wedding theme. Get a pretty box and fill it up with mini champagne bottles, face masks, robes, and a personalised card.

Tip: Look for printable labels, box templates, and inspiration from websites like Etsy (so it looks personalised but you don’t have to be the one slaving over it if you do not have a creative bone in you)

2. Mini Cupcakes

Organise a simple get-together with your girlfriends and surprise them with customised “will you be my bridesmaid” cupcakes.

Be sure to include vegan and gluten-free options so that it remains a delicious and yet thoughtful invitation to the party.

3. Mini Champagne Bottles

This is a fun and refreshing way to include them in your wedding party.

You can opt for delicious flavours such as tropical mango, zesty grapefruit, mandarin, and strawberry mimosas.

It is also perfect for you to toast each of them to honor their presence at your upcoming nuptials.

4. Thoughtful Letter

Keep it simple, stupid. If you are like me and you are far from being creative, why don’t you just pen down a simple handwritten letter?

Sure, it might not be IG worthy like other fancy bridesmaid proposals but it will truly tug at their heartstrings.

Some pointers for the letter:

– Talk about how you met this person
– How they have helped you grow into your own
– How special they are
– Why is it important for them to stand up for you on your big day
– End with gratitude for their presence

5. Personalised Time Capsule

Pick out cherished mementos from years of your friendship and include them in a time capsule.

6. Customise A Puzzle

Again, this is easy to order from Etsy. You can either include a picture/ the phrase “will you be my bridesmaid”.

7. Flowers & A Card

Who doesn’t enjoy the smell of fresh flowers? You can either hand-deliver it or surprise them when they are at work. Include a sweet note to remind them how special they are.

8. Play Me A Love Song

If you are musically inclined, invite your girls over for a mini jam session. Surprise them with a song you made. End the beautiful night with a charcuterie tray and some sweet treats.

See, it doesn’t always have to be expensive or over the top!

9. Scratch Off Card

Surprise them with a scratch-off card which reveals the words “will you be my beautiful bridesmaid?”

10. Cookies For The Win

Order up some customised scrumptious cookies for your girl squad.

Some popular phrases include “Team Bride or Will You Walk With Me and “It Wouldn’t Be A Bridal Party Without You.”

It will be almost too pretty to eat.

11. Jewellery Box

Who says only the bride gets to have new jewellery? Opt for beautiful and timeless earrings/ bracelets that they can use for both the wedding and for future events.

12. Light My Fire, Girls!

Why not opt for a customised candle with the words “Smells Like Bridesmaid Duties Beckons” or “Light This To Help Soothe The Bride’s Stress”?

Personalised soy candles are all the rage on Etsy.

13. Take A Trip Together

It doesn’t have to be expensive, but it could be a staycation that you host. Then you can surprise them with some inexpensive décor on whether they will be bridesmaids.

14. Self-Care Basket

You’ll want your bridesmaids to be well taken care of before they take on the task of caring for you on your big day. Include the following as you ask them the big question:

– Eye mask
– Bathrobe
– Essential oils
– Hot cocoa
– Journal
– Body lotion
– Fuzzy socks
– Nuts & dried fruits

15. TikTok-Inspired Proposal Video

Use social media to your advantage.

Edit old videos and photos that you have together. Include some lovely music and complete it with the caption “Will you be my bridesmaid?”

This works very well for long-distance friendships and costs 0.

16. A Story Book

I am sure you are wondering what this even means. Well, think of writing a real-life story book of your entire friendship and end the last page with the ultimate question!

17. Customised T-shirts

This can be perfect for your bridal shower/ bachelorette party.

Get a matching t-shirt. Bride Tribe, anyone? You can also customise their names on each shirt with the words “Bridesmaid Est 2025” or “Girl Squad 2025” on the back.

18. Mini Terrarium with a Note

A simple but touching gesture.

This goes well with your nature-loving, eco-loving bridesmaid. Include a cheeky punny note that says, “Help me grow into a beautiful bride – will you be my bridesmaid?”

19. Recite It With Vows

Elevate your bridesmaid proposal by reciting a vow for every one.

List out 10 vows that you promise you will/ won’t do during this stressful period.

This is your chance to make it hilarious for your guests. But make sure you end up walking the talk, girl!

Where to Find Bridesmaid Proposal Gifts

There are a ton of marketplaces that offer ready-made bridesmaid proposal gifts, but here are my favorites:

– Etsy – Handmade, unique, and often customizable
– Target / Walmart – In-person finds like candles, mugs, and robes
– Amazon – Budget-friendly options, and there are fast shipping options
– Canva – For designing your cards or tags

4 Crucial Tips for the Perfect Bridesmaid Proposal

1. Make It Personal

Understand your bridesmaids’ personalities. Some are introverted and may not be crazy about the social media shout-outs, whilst others might revel in it.

It might mean more time spent to curate personal experiences, but I promise you, the extra effort will show up in a big way on your wedding day.

So be sure to include a personal touch every step of the way.

2. Craft Out A Budget

I believe in inexpensive bridesmaid proposals. After all, as a bride, you already have a ton of expenses on your head.

The key is to do something from your heart and not your wallet.

3. Think Of Delivery Options

– In person: Great for creating a photo/ video op and recording their happy reactions.
– Mail: Perfect for out-of-town bridesmaids. Be sure to pack those fragile gifts carefully so that they arrive beautifully to them/
– Virtual: Use a video call or email with digital artwork or a slideshow. There are so many templates on Canva that you can easily utilise to help you pull this off.

4. Figure Out The Best Timing

From my own experience as a bride and bridesmaid, you’ll want to do this right after you get engaged.

To be specific, you are looking at 9 – 12 months before the actual wedding day.

Remember that your bridesmaids will have to block off their calendars multiple days before the actual wedding. So, please be thoughtful and considerate.

Lasting Thoughts

All in all, you want the sentiment of asking your girlfriends to be sweet and customised to their unique personalities.

This is a chance to flex those creativity muscles if you are into that. But if you are not, that is okay too. Keep it simple and sweet.

Whether you are going to go all out on planning a trip or keeping it to just a sentimental handwritten letter, your squad is going to feel super special to be included in your big day.

So go on ahead and get that bridesmaid proposal going!

19 Bridesmaid Proposal Ideas They’ll Never Forget – It May Make Them Cry